Reviewed by Casual Debris
https://casualdebris.blogspot.com/2012/04/anthony-berkeley-trial-and-error-1937.html
(From the archives)
Supposedly Chandler did not much like this story himself and regarded it as inauthentic, a story written for Saturday Evening Post
rather than one of the pulps he usually favored. It has all of the
elements of a typical pulp crime story: a house dick, a femme fatale,
the man she is waiting for, the man who is waiting for him. But a heck
of a lot of the story spends its time describing the hotel--in fact, we
know more about the hotel than we do about any of the characters.
Perhaps you need to read more of this sort of story to get it. I have
to admit though, I could draw a picture of that hotel from lobby, to
bar, to elevator, to penthouses. If I could draw, that is.
In their anthology of hardboiled fiction, editors Bill Pronzini and Jack Adrian regard the story as “a superbly atmospheric night-piece” and respond, “Chandler was a perceptive critic of others’ work, although less so of his own.” Indeed, still frequently included in anthologies, the story today is considered by many readers and critics as among his best and most polished (with a superb twist ending), and it has even been adapted for film twice, most recently in 1993 as an episode of Showtime’s Fallen Angels directed by Tom Hanks.
From the website Story of the Week, Library of Congress.
Sarasota is the vacation spot for a large group of Mennonites so the streets are filled with them on bicycles wearing their distinctive dress. I saw my brother and his wife, and went to a Tigers preseason game with visiting friends. Who could ask for anything more? Maybe a less hectic trip home.
I enjoyed the movie TRAIN DREAMS but mostly we seemed to watch GRACE, which is on Britbox. I am not much for streaming night after night but my friends love to watch that way. Are you a streamer or do you prefer to stretch it out? I very much enjoyed reading THE CORRESPONDENT and one or two other novels.
What about you?
Took two days to get home with our flight cancelled and another one hard to come by. I will be back in force by Monday but probably not till then.
One of my favorite books about Hollywood, Otto Friedrich looks at it from 1939 until 1950. A very particular time because of the influx of Europeans fleeing Nazi Germany. Many of what would be the most talented directors and actors turned up to escape the regime and the war. Blacklisting figures heavily in this period too. This is a terrific book for anyone interested in this era and the movie business, or the politics of that time.
Tracy mentioned reading THE PRIME OF MISS JEAN BRODIE and I read this collection in 2020.
"The Leafsweeper" has the odd premise of being about a man whose obsession was putting an end to the celebration of Christmas. When enough people were bored and tired with his ranting about it, he was put in an asylum where he rakes leaves In the house where he formerly ranted, another ghostly figure takes his place at Christmas time although he does not rant and rave about Christmas. The story ends with the two figures becoming one. One has to wonder what the man does when there are no leaves to rake.
"The House of the Famous Poet" was even stranger. A woman living in the house of a famous poet is on a train ride when a soldier sells her "an abstract funeral" to cover the costs of his fare. The story ends with a bombing where people in the house of the famous poet die thus requiring a real funeral.
And finally "The Executor." A woman's uncle dies and leaves her his house and estate. She turns over his literary work to a foundation, holding back a novel about a witch with a chapter left for completion. As she works to complete it, little notes turn up each day, chastising her for not finishing the work and making disturbing accusations. The Foundation notifies her that they were in receipt of the final chapter and wanted the rest of it.
None of these were satisfying to me as ghost stories but as I said, I enjoyed them anyway. Sometimes the conceit is more interesting than a satisfying conclusion. I always like Spark's writing and these were stories from a quirky mind. The best kind, I think. I have also enjoyed a number of her novels.
Finished BUCKEYE and it really was a great novel. I will look for his earlier one (Patrick Ryan). It reminded me of a novel from the last century in that it was chronological in its telling and was gentle on its characters. Also watching THE PITT, (more frightening than ever) and the GAME OF THRONES prequel, which I like too. Also DROPS OF GOD on APPLE. And SHRINKING. Finished ALL CREATURES GREAT AND SMALL. Emma Thompson's daughter looks just like her. That is such a calming show but I am glad the War is over.
Weather here is improved. I go to FL for three weeks next Monday. I will put this up in case you want to stop by.
What about you?
Kevin, a long time ago.
"For a Long Time This Was Griselda's Story "
This is one strange story about a circus stunt I had never heard of. A man who can eat metal. And huge amounts of it. Esmerelda is a high school student who plays volleyball and one day goes to the circus with her sister and is mesmerized by an act where a very non-descript man is able to consume metal. She is so enamored that she runs away with him breaking her mother and sister's heart.
Over the years, she sends postcards from all of the places she has seen. Her sister does not show these cards to her mother and eventually the mother dies never knowing her daughter was okay all of those years. A lot of the story describes the act in great detail. Did you know their were circus acts like this one?
Did not do much outside the home.
Watched STEAL, THE PITT, THE SEVENTH KNIGHT, Saw the movie SEASONAL VALUES again with some friends.
Had dinner at a great Chinese Restaurant.
Read the graphic novel, THEY CALLED US ENEMY by George Takei and BUCKEYE (Patrick Ryan)
How about you?
reviewed by TracyK
February, 1940. In San Francisco's Chinatown, fireworks explode as the city celebrates Chinese New Year with a Rice Bowl Party, a three day-and-night carnival designed to raise money and support for China war relief. Miranda Corbie is a 33-year-old private investigator who stumbles upon the fatally shot body of Eddie Takahashi. The Chamber of Commerce wants it covered up. The cops acquiesce. All Miranda wants is justice--whatever it costs. From Chinatown tenements, to a tattered tailor's shop in Little Osaka, to a high-class bordello draped in Southern Gothic, she shakes down the city–her city–seeking the truth.
From the archives (oh, how we miss you)
tories
Bradbury wrote for such pulps as Dime Mystery Magazine and New
Detective Magazine. Most of the stories appeared between 1944 and 1946.
I've probably read this book four or five times over the years. It has
the energy and inventiveness of all good pulp with the bonus of watching
a young writer struggle to find the voice that is really his. In
several of the stories we hear the voice that Bradbury will later
perfect. He's often proclaimed his admiration of Cornell Woolrich and
here we see the dark Woolrich influence, especially in the excellent
"The Candy Skull" (Mexico has long fascinated Bradbury; here it's
nightmare Mexico), "The Trunk Lady" and (what a title) "Corpse
Carnival." One of Bradbury's most famous stories is here also, "The
Small Assassin," written for a penny a word for Dime Mystery Magazine in
1946.The most interesting story is "The Long Night." I remember the
editor who bought it writing a piece years later about what a find it
was. And it is. A story set in the Hispanic area of Los Angeles during
the war, it deals with race and race riots, with the juvenile
delinquency that was a major problem for this country in the war years
(remember The Amboy Dukes?) and the the paternal bonds that teenage boys
need and reject at the same time. A haunting, powerful story that hints
at the greatness that was only a few years away from Bradbury.What can I
tell you? I love this book. At its least it's a pure pulp romp and at
its best it's the master about to change science fiction forever. And
making a memorable pass at making his mark on crime fiction as well.
I enjoyed my eleven days in CA. The weather could have been warmer but it also could have been colder like almost anywhere else. I think I am done with CA though after ten trips there. I go to Sarasota in three weeks. Both plane rides were smooth and on time.
Our condo was right on the water and we saw some fabulous sunsets. Lots of great meals: Vietnamese, Middle Eastern, Thai, Fish. I watched both playoff games for the first time ever.
Read THE POSTMAN's FIANCE after THE LONELY POSTMAN (Denis Theriault) which was okay.
Started THE DROPS OF GOLD on Apple. This is the second season. The final THE NIGHT MANAGER is on February 1, I think. I watched the first episode of the second season of HI-JACK, which takes place on a train instead of a plane. Been revisiting CURB YOUR ENTHUSIASM. Started SHRINKING.
What about you? Are you keeping warm?